Questions

How do you structure a small business with one partner as investor and another in charge of operations?

I was just offered a potentially lucrative business proposition wherein I am required to invest about $250,000 per transaction with between 2% to 4% ROI. The business proposer will manage all operational duties. If I was to go ahead, how should the business be structured? What are the steps I can take to protect my investment? How should any potential net income be shared if the proposer does not invest a single penny? What are the pitfalls of such an arrangement? Any other suggestions and advice would be highly appreciated.

4answers

What you're asking is very complex and to me 2% to 4% seems like a terrible ROI. There is a lot of information that needs to be provided to determine how to structure the deal and if it's even a good deal. Are you getting equity (a part of the ownership of the company) for your investment? If yes, how much (%)? Is the company valuation realistic? Is the company established and having sales or is it just starting out?

Simple example: If you're investing 250k $ and the company has a realistic pre-money (before your money is invested in it) valuation of 1 Million $, you should be getting 25% in terms of equity. Of course things aren't that simple in reality but it's a good rule of thumb.

- If I was to go ahead, how should the business be structured?
This is hard to answer without more information. In general you should seek to have both equity and decision making power if you're investing into a business, if you want to be an equal partner you need both equal equity and power. Especially if it's in an early stage or if you're investing a significant amount of money. Which to me seems to be the case. How you'll specifically structure the business depends on the area in which the business operates in ex. software, manufacturing, sales, consulting etc.

- What are the steps I can take to protect my investment?
A lot of research and consulting into how these kinds of investments are usually done. You should obviously have a specific contract drafted by a lawyer as well which denotes the terms of investment.

- How should any potential net income be shared if the proposer does not invest a single penny?
Depends on what else is the proposer bringing to the table. Maybe other resources, machines for manufacturing, their network, blood sweat and tears, or whatever has a determinable value. Of course you need to figure out if what they're bringing to the table is of equal or more value to the money you're bringing in.

- What are the pitfalls of such an arrangement?
Also depends on the details. Some are:
-> Giving the partner all the decision making power, "Trust is a terrible criteria for investment"
-> There's always the risk of the company failing of course.
-> If you don't draft specific contracts on what you're getting for your investment chances are you'll be getting very little

I would suggest reading up/researching on investing into businesses (or start-ups), there are established procedures and contracts that are often used when investing.


Answered 11 days ago

It is noticeably clear from your question that you are hinting towards a broad business model because it is taking external forces like investment are taken into consideration. Major pitfalls in this model are not sufficiently focusing on the core value creating processes and it includes factors not completely controlled by the company.
Besides if you do have any questions give me a call: https://clarity.fm/joy-brotonath


Answered 11 days ago

First things first, you should do your assessment, due diligence of the person offering you this opportunity and the assessment of the offer and underlying business model.

Do you know this person, do you have an established trusting relationship?
Does this person have successful and verifiable business traction in the same field?
Are there any references you can check?

Also, assess what you could do alternatively with the capital that you would invest here? A comparison of the opportunities' type, risk profile, ROI etc will make it easier to decide if this is even a relevant opportunity for you or not.


Answered 8 days ago

Hi there.

My initial thoughts here is that the risk/reward payoff of between 2 and 4% seems low. In essence, this deal feels more akin to a venture capital proposition (seed capital), if the business proposer takes onboard all operational activities and doesn't invest anything. More information here would be helpful regarding this point, but under this form of deal, I'd be seeking a much higher return on my investment.

Secondly, and to the point of others on this thread, what percentage of the business does your $250k buy into? Has the proposer invested anything or provided anything of tangible value to the business (product, invention, patent, active customers, confirmed orders, etc.)? It's important here to understand what exactly your $250k (per transaction) is buying into.

Another question I'd be asking, is what will the funds be used for and what level of comfort do you have that it will be well managed and equate to growth/value.

Also, how many others (if any) will potentially also be investing (both now and into the future). The more invested, the further your return is diluted.

Knowing these aspects, one potential structure here is that you could be an equity parter with x% ownership (based on the above factors) of the business. I would however caveat this by urging caution and making sure I did a thorough assessment of all the angles presented here before progressing. There is some good general advice here so far from a few of the members and I hope these give you some good ideas on how to proceed. Feel free to reach out or to ask more questions here.


Answered 7 days ago

Unlock Startups Unlimited

Access 20,000+ Startup Experts, 650+ masterclass videos, 1,000+ in-depth guides, and all the software tools you need to launch and grow quickly.

Already a member? Sign in

Copyright © 2021 Startups.com LLC. All rights reserved.